Glen Mitchell's Real Estate Blog

head_left_image

Do mobile and manufactured homes appreciate in value???

line graph

 

 

Do mobile homes and manufactured homes increase in value or decrease???  This is a question often asked when talking about manufactured homes.  In fact, on a recent web post I saw the following as a realtor's answer to a potential buyers question about value....

"No, do not buy a mobile/manufactured home! Rent instead. Mobile homes don't appreciate and they are difficult to sell. Check Craig's list, there are quite a few for sale and no buyers. Don't throw your money away."

He must know what he's talking about.  He's licensed right?  Why don't we help out and provide some actual data and see what the results are...  the Realtor happens to be in the Santa Clara County area, so we will start there.  I was able to get Sold averages since 1998 from the multiple listing service.  We need to compare against other types of property to get a good idea if the numbers are good or bad, so let’s find out the appreciation or depreciation of single family homes, condos, and mobile/manufactured homes,(in community park settings, both owner and non owner owned parks) from 1998 to the second half of 2008.

Here's the results for Santa Clara County.... Drum roll please....

Single family homes appreciated 128%

Condos appreciated 126%

Mobile/Manufactured homes appreciated 83%

 

So each form of housing appreciated a fairly decent amount although manufactured homes trailed in 3rd place.  Maybe this is just a fluke??  Lets look at the counties to the north and south and compare.

San Mateo County to the north....

Single family homes appreciated 152%

Condos appreciated 117%

And mobile/manufactured homes 143% 

Single Family homes win again, but not by much.  Sorry condo owners you take third place this time.

 

Maybe our agent above was referring to Santa Cruz county, so same time period we have...

Single family homes appreciate 152%

Condos appreciated 92%

And Mobile/manufactured homes 144%

Pretty similar to San Mateo County numbers, and unfortunately condos come in third again.  Granted this is the California Bay Area we are talking about, but it appears all forms of housing increased a large percentage over the time period we have data for.  It also appears that returns on mobile/manufactured homes in two counties were even higher than returns on condos and within 9% of the returns on single family homes in two counties.  Is our data flawed?  What would happen if we took out mobile homes built prior to the HUD code?  We will save that for a future post, but I'm guessing our manufactured home returns may go up even higher.  Is someone trying to sabotage the manufactured home industry?  Did we not have a big enough sample?  In Santa Clara we are talking about 6082 mobile/manufactured home sales.  If we average that out over 10 years and then divide by 4 to get an even quarterly number we come up with 152 sales a quarter are needed to keep this pace.  So we have to have at least that may homes listed.  152 Craigslists ads which might represent a lot from our realtor quote above.  It sounds like a lot.  As a side note and scary thought right before Halloween, the approx return in the Dow Jones Industrial average over the same time period ending today was 1.5%.  Yikes, I bet more investors wish they had parked their money in mobile and manufactured homes.

Speaking of money, and being a former equity options floor trader, at first glance it looks like there are some good spread opportunities here.  IE sell Santa Clara Condos and buy Santa Clara homes or maybe sell San Mateo manufactured homes and buy Santa Clara manufactured homes.  Ok, so we are probably getting carried away here and need to do some more research, but I would really consider the Santa Clara one if I owned a condo there.

I hope you liked this data and if you have data from other parts of the United States I hope you take the time to post so we can compare.  Sign up for new posts to the manufactured and modular home group.  I'm sure there are lots of info and ideas for us all to learn from. 

Thanks, Glen Mitchell

Info on average prices for blog taken from mlslistings is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed.

About the Author: The above info was provided by Glen Mitchell, licensed Real Estate Broker in California (#01345619) and Hawaii(#18416). Glen can be reached via email at glenmitchell@kw.com or by phone at 650-260-4536.

 

                                                   

Have a home to sell in the California Bay Area? I'd be happy to share my marketing expertise and experience with you!

For MLS access and no obligation real estate listing searches, begin by clicking here.

www.glenmitchellgroup.com

www.coastalrentalslp.com

www.halfmoonbay4rent.com

I service the following Counties: San Mateo, San Francisco, Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, Monterey, and Maui.  Partial list of cities include Half Moon Bay, El Granada, Montara, Moss Beach, Hillsborough, Burlingame, Atherton, Palo Alto, Woodside, Pescadero, Pacifica, Daly City, Los Altos, Soquel, Aptos, Capitola, Scotts valley, Kihei, Wailea and more.

Click here to view Glen Mitchell's Real Estate Profile.

Click here for property management info.

Comment balloon 8 commentsGlen A. Mitchell • October 24 2008 07:28PM

Comments

Bravo!!!

Posted by Stacy Potts (Reserve Financial & Properties) over 10 years ago

This drives me crazy...I agree that this is a common misconception. Many people don't fully understand the difference between a manufactured home affixed to land with an eliminated title...and a manufactured home in a park. The bottom line is this is the most affordable housing available throughout many parts of the country. I believe there will be a market for manufactured homes for years to come (as long as the lenders don't close out all manufactured home loan programs).

Anyhow...from what I understand the majority of manufactured homes built today have very high construction standards. As a past realtor who specialized in new construction...I have seen many, many stick built homes, built WAY too cheaply...that started falling apart prior to completion of construction.

I'm not saying they are ALL well built...but you take a well constructed manufacture home... affix the home to land, and as long as there are loan programs to finance these properties...they will follow the appreciation of the local market and demand from consumers for that price point :)

Posted by Brooke Villano (The Legacy Group) over 9 years ago

MY HUSBAND AND I ARE LOOKING INTO BUYING A MODULAR HOME.  I MUST SAY I WAS AMAZED ON HOW BEAUTIFUL THER ARE.  YET, I AM SCARRED.  WHAT IF IT FALLS APART TWO YEARS DOWN THE ROAD?  WHAT IF WE DECIDE TO SELL IT TEN YEARS LATER?  DO THEY HOLD THEIR VALUE AND DO THEY LAST?????  THIS IS A HUGE INVESTMENT FOR US AND DO NOT WANT ANY REGRETS!!

Posted by SUSAN about 9 years ago

Hi Susan,  what are of the country are you in?  when you say modular I typically thing of a factory home being built to be placed on a private lot.  Is that what you are planning?  Manufactured homes can also go on a foundation but typically are used in manufactured home parks.  Here is a link to a video series I just did putting a manufactured home on a private lot with a cement foundation.  http://www.youtube.com/user/mitchellinvestments

This home is not going to fall apart in two years.  Yikes if it did I sure would be in trouble.  If you can provide some more details about your plans and the type of home you are looking at buying, where its going, etc I can give you some more pointers and opinions on value etc. 

Thanks for posting...

Glen Mitchell

Broker and Manufactured Home Dealer

Posted by Glen Mitchell about 9 years ago

Hello Glen,

 

We are looking at investing in a mobile home or modular home in OC CA so that my sister and her husband can live there. It seems like the best bet for the money right now but the slot rent is horrendous. How can we go about finding land in OC to possibly put a house on or buy a slot in a mobile home park. Are these even options?

Posted by Vanessa almost 8 years ago

Hi Vanessa,

Thanks for checking in.  I would need to know some more info in terms of how much money you were looking at investing??  Email me directly at glenmitchell@remax.net with some of the details.  Different parks have different space rents based on if they are owner occupied park sites, owned by a park owner/manager/ corporation, or if its in a rent controlled area.  You can go the land route too, but then price becomes a factor.  So check back in and we can figure out some options for you.  Glen

Posted by Glen A. Mitchell, Broker, CDPE, Santa Cruz, Half Moon Bay,El Granada (Keller Williams Peninsula Estates) almost 8 years ago

Hi Glen,

Do you still observe appreciation in manufactured homes prices in Santa Clara county?

(In year 2012)

I met few agents that were claiming so. Do you have any data  available?

Many thanks in advance!

Ania

 

Posted by ania over 6 years ago

I know I'm a little late to the party but I just found this post in the AR archives and wanted to invite you to join my group: 

http://activerain.com/groups/manufacturedhomes

You have a lot of very valid information here and I'm happy to see someone else out there in the RE world telling it like it really is. Keep em coming. and if you ever want to use any of my information just let me know. I'd be happy to network with you anytime.

Posted by John DL Arendsen, Crest Backyard Homes "ADU" dealer & Contractor (CREST BACKYARD HOMES, ON THE LEVEL GENERAL & FACTORY BUILT HOME CONTRACTOR, TAG REAL ESTATE SALES & INVESTMENTS) over 5 years ago

Participate